A good song is a good song...

In the Songwriting Secrets Interview I did, we talked about how 'a good song is a good song' no matter which way you cut it. What I mean by that is, we all love songs - and we all hate songs.

But do you recognize the genius of the songs that you hate?

There are some songs out there which I don't particularly like, BUT, I know that they are GOOD songs. I know they have a good melodically structure, and nice chord progression and some captivating lyrics.

A good way to gauge what is a good song is... can it be sung or played in another style or format successfully? Can it come across as magical as the original - although you may not like the actual genre in question?

I have picked a Bob Dylan song in this example. I've found 4 different versions of the same song, and I'm sure there bucket loads more. But I think everyone here has done a good job - but more importantly, the song itself is a good one.

The song almost lends itself across the board of different musical styles.

It's truly amazing. Check these out...

Bob Dylan...



Stevie Wonder...



Katie Melua...



Sam Cooke...



Post your comments...